How to Choose an SEO Agency in 2027: 7 Questions, Red Flags and a Scorecard

Hiring an SEO agency is hard because the people selling the service are also the ones explaining how to judge it. This guide flips that: it uses Google’s own guidance on hiring an SEO, adds what I look for after working on search for a long time, and gives you a scorecard you can use on any provider — including us.

“

If an SEO will not explain what they are changing and why, they are not doing SEO for you. They are doing it to you.

— Mateusz Maslon, SEO/GEO Specialist 🎯 LinkedIn ↗

Quick Answer: How Do You Choose an SEO Agency?

Ask for proof, a plan and transparency, and walk away from guarantees. Google’s guidance on hiring an SEO boils down to seven questions (examples of past work, compliance with Google Search Essentials, expected results and how they are measured, relevant experience, time in business, willingness to explain every change, and real interest in your business) and a short list of red flags: unsolicited offers, guaranteed #1 rankings, a “special relationship” with Google, secrecy and link requests.

Infographic: how to choose an SEO agency, seven questions to ask and the red flags to avoid, based on Google guidance

For the basics of what a good SEO provider should be doing, read SEO Foundations in 2027. For the question many people ask first, see Is SEO Dead?.

Do You Need an SEO Agency at All?

Not always. Google’s documentation describes SEO as work you can do yourself, hire out entirely or get specific help with. Many sites need a one-time audit and a prioritized fix list rather than a long retainer. Before you hire anyone, know what you want: an audit, implementation help, ongoing monthly work, or a migration. Providers are different for each, and so are prices.

7 Questions to Ask Before You Hire

These are the questions Google itself suggests asking a potential SEO, with what I think a good answer sounds like.

1. Can you show examples of past work and success stories?

A good answer includes specific sites, what was changed and what moved, in numbers you can verify. Be cautious of screenshots with no context. Ask whether the results came from search, and over what period.

2. Do you follow Google Search Essentials?

The honest answer is yes, and a good provider can name what that means: crawlable and indexable pages, original people-first content and no spam tactics such as link schemes or mass-produced pages. If they hedge, that is your answer.

3. What results do you expect, over what timeframe, and how do you measure success?

A legitimate SEO gives realistic estimates, not promises. Google says changes can take from a few hours to several months to show up. Measurement should be tied to your goals: indexed pages, impressions, clicks, leads — not only rankings.

4. What experience do you have in my industry, country or city, and with international sites?

Relevant experience shortens the learning curve. It is not a deal-breaker if it is thin, but the provider should say so and explain how they would fill the gap.

5. How long have you been in business?

Longevity is not quality, but it tells you whether the person has seen several Google changes and AI search shifts, or only the last one.

6. Will you share every change you make and explain your reasoning?

This is the question that exposes the most. You are responsible for what is done to your site. Insist on a change log and a reason for each change.

7. Are you interested in my business, my customers and my competitors?

A provider who starts with keywords and never asks who your customers are is selling a template. SEO that works starts with what people actually want from you.

“

The first call tells you everything. If the first thing they say is a number you should expect, run. If the first thing they ask is who your customers are, stay.

— Mateusz Maslon, SEO/GEO Specialist 🎯 LinkedIn ↗

Red Flags: When to Walk Away

  • Unsolicited offers. Google advises treating unsolicited SEO emails with the same skepticism as scams.
  • A guaranteed #1 ranking. Google says plainly that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.
  • A “special relationship” with Google or “priority submit”. There is no such thing for organic search.
  • Secrecy or an unclear plan. Google warns that deceptive tactics can get your site removed from its index and that you are responsible for what companies you hire do.
  • Links to them, link schemes or submission to “thousands of search engines”. These are signs of the practices Google calls link spam.
  • A tool or service “approved by Google”. Google does not evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools.

Cheap does not prove a scam, but very low monthly fees for broad promises usually mean automated work. Always ask what exactly the monthly price buys.

How to Protect Yourself

Check references

Ask for contacts at past clients and ask whether the SEO was useful, easy to work with and delivered positive results.

Limit access

Google recommends that if you ask for an audit you limit access: grant read-only Search Console access and withhold write access. Keep ownership of your site, analytics and Search Console accounts in your name, always.

Check their advice against Google’s documentation

Ask where a recommendation comes from. This matters most for AI search, where hype is loud. Google says you do not need new machine-readable files, AI text files or special markup to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, so a provider selling llms.txt as a solution should be able to show you why. See Does llms.txt work? for the evidence.

What a Good First 90 Days Looks Like

This part is my experience, not Google documentation. A sensible start has three stages:

  1. Audit. A review of technical, content and external signals ending in a prioritized fix list. See our SEO audit for what that covers.
  2. Fix the blockers first. Indexing, crawl access, duplicate URLs and slow or broken pages come before any new content.
  3. Report and adjust. A regular report with what changed, what moved and what happens next. Measure indexing, impressions and clicks in Search Console.

What Does an SEO Agency Cost?

There is no single price, and I will not quote one. What you pay depends on the size and complexity of your site, its current technical condition, whether you want a one-off audit, an implementation project or ongoing monthly work, and how much reporting you need. Be wary of any provider who quotes a final price before looking at your site. If you want to see how we think about it, see monthly SEO management and technical SEO.

SEO Agency Scorecard

Score each candidate on these seven criteria. If a provider fails on three or more, keep looking.

CriterionGood signRed flag
ProofSpecific, verifiable results with contextScreenshots, vague claims, no references
PlanAudit first, prioritized fixes, clear scopeOne package for everyone
TimelineRealistic ranges, ongoing reviewGuaranteed results in days or weeks
MeasurementIndexing, impressions, clicks, leadsOnly keyword rankings or “traffic”
TransparencyChange log and reasoning for every changeSecrecy, “proprietary methods”
MethodsFollows Google Search EssentialsLink schemes, mass pages, cheap tricks
AccessRead-only access, you own all accountsAsks for owner access to everything

A Note About Us

We sell SEO services too, so the honest thing is to say it: use this scorecard on us. We publish our audit process, explain what we do not do on every service page and offer free tools to check your own site first, including a free SEO audit tool and a free GEO audit tool. If you decide on someone else after reading this, the article did its job.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose an SEO company?

Ask for verifiable proof, a clear plan and full transparency about every change. Use Google’s seven questions: examples of past work, compliance with Google Search Essentials, expected results and measurement, relevant experience, time in business, willingness to explain changes and interest in your business.

What are the red flags of a bad SEO agency?

Unsolicited offers, guaranteed #1 rankings, claims of a special relationship with Google or priority submission, secrecy about methods, requests to link to them, link schemes, and tools or services described as approved by Google.

Can an SEO agency guarantee a first-page ranking?

No. Google states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google. A legitimate SEO can give realistic estimates of improvement and of the work involved.

How much does an SEO agency cost?

It depends on the size and complexity of the site, its technical condition, the scope (audit, project or monthly work) and the amount of reporting. Be cautious of a fixed price quoted without looking at your site.

How long does SEO take to work?

Google says changes can take from a few hours to several months to show up, and suggests waiting a few weeks before judging results.

What access should I give an SEO agency?

Read-only access to Search Console for an audit, with write access withheld until you trust the provider. You should always own your website, analytics and Search Console accounts.

Conclusion: Hire for Honesty First

The best SEO provider is the one who tells you what they will do, what they will not do and how you will know it worked. Use the seven questions, watch for the red flags and keep ownership of your accounts. Then compare the answers to what you read in the foundations of SEO, and you will recognize quality when you hear it.

Related reading: what a good monthly report looks like, with our free SEO report template and example.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 1

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Share your love
MaslonLabs
MaslonLabs

At Maslon Labs, we are passionate about the Android ecosystem. We noticed that many apps are cluttered with unnecessary features, so we decided to do things differently. Our goal is to deliver the "best-in-class" experience through minimalist design and robust functionality. Every app we release is crafted with care, ensuring that you get the most out of your device without the headache of a steep learning curve.

Articles: 105